Difference between revisions of "Billie"

From Life of Onion
Jump to: navigation, search
(long ass video whew. now for part two D':)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 53: Line 53:
 
Greg uploaded two "[[I Betrayed My Wife]]" videos to his [[Speaks]] channel going into detail about what happened between him, Billie, and Kai. He revealed he and Kai were going to [[Marriage Counseling|counseling]] to work on their marriage. ([https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8RNbzscfXQ $ource])
 
Greg uploaded two "[[I Betrayed My Wife]]" videos to his [[Speaks]] channel going into detail about what happened between him, Billie, and Kai. He revealed he and Kai were going to [[Marriage Counseling|counseling]] to work on their marriage. ([https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8RNbzscfXQ $ource])
  
The three of them received individual backlash from viewers for the events that took place. Billie in particular was labeled a "homewrecker" and was shunned by Greg and Kai as well as a majority of their fans. It is worth noting Greg and Kai's audience were not very familiar with Billie at this point as she only appeared in a couple of video.
+
The three of them received individual backlash from viewers for the events that took place. Billie in particular was labeled a "homewrecker" and was shunned by Greg and Kai as well as a majority of their fans. It is worth noting Greg and Kai's audience were not very familiar with Billie at this point as she only appeared in a couple of videos.
  
 
Greg released a prank "Re: Re: Re: I Betrayed My Wife" video to his comedy channel, pretending he and Kai broke up again. Billie thought it was real and sent Greg a text saying she caught feelings for him and and was ready for a relationship. Greg uploaded another fake "I Betrayed My Wife" to his comedy channel revealing the previous video was fake. He showed the text in his video and gave everyone that believed him the middle finger. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:BillieText.png Source])
 
Greg released a prank "Re: Re: Re: I Betrayed My Wife" video to his comedy channel, pretending he and Kai broke up again. Billie thought it was real and sent Greg a text saying she caught feelings for him and and was ready for a relationship. Greg uploaded another fake "I Betrayed My Wife" to his comedy channel revealing the previous video was fake. He showed the text in his video and gave everyone that believed him the middle finger. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:BillieText.png Source])
Line 73: Line 73:
 
After the video, Kai briefly deleted his twitter. When his twitter returned, the "dramatic" tweets were deleted and the cycle continued.
 
After the video, Kai briefly deleted his twitter. When his twitter returned, the "dramatic" tweets were deleted and the cycle continued.
  
Greg later went on to explain some of their temporary break ups in a video. He explains Billie went to a concert and "multiple people" informed Kai that Billie appeared "extremely" high. (Note: It is well known that Greg does not allow his partners to smoke.) He says after the concert, Billie contacted him and Kai to ask if she would ever make "physical contact" with another guy. Greg says because he and Kai view this as a serious relationship, they said no. He explains allowing her to be with another guy would make their relationship "causal", therefor "meaningless." Greg says Billie told them she did not make physical contact with a guy, but Kai was informed of a photo of Billie holding another guy's hand at a concert while on his shoulders. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:BillieMakesContactWithAMaleReeee2016.png Pic]) Greg marks this as the first lie Billie told them. He says they broke up with Billie over this, but they soon forgave her and took her back. Since Billie's friend Ayalla tried to defend Billie to him over the phone during this time, Greg concludes Ayalla defends Billie over anything, even if Billie is wrong and calls them "partners in crime."
+
Greg later went on to explain some of their temporary break ups in a video. He explains Billie went to a concert and "multiple people" informed Kai that Billie appeared extremely high. (Note: It is well known that Greg does not allow his partners to smoke.) He says after the concert, Billie contacted him and Kai to ask if she could ever make "physical contact" with another guy. Greg says because he and Kai view this as a serious relationship, they said no. He explains allowing her to be with another guy would make their relationship "causal", therefor "meaningless." Greg says Billie told them she did not make physical contact with a guy, but Kai was informed of a photo of Billie holding another guy's hand at a concert while sitting on his shoulders. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:BillieMakesContactWithAMaleReeee2016.png Pic]) Greg marks this as the first lie Billie told them. He says they broke up with Billie over this, but they soon forgave her and took her back. Since Billie's friend Ayalla tried to defend Billie to him over the phone during this time, Greg concludes Ayalla defends Billie over anything, even if Billie is wrong and calls them "partners in crime."
  
Greg says during this time, Billie managed his social media and was paid $1,800 a month for it. He says she was previously working at Target, but her schedule prevented her from hanging out with them. He mentions a perk of her working as a contractor for him was that she could fly out and hang out with them.  
+
Greg says during this time, Billie managed his social media and was paid $1,800 a month for it. He says she was previously working at Target, but her schedule prevented her from hanging out with them. He mentions a perk of her working as a contractor for him was that she could fly out to hang out with them.  
  
 
Greg says he and Kai wanted to look through Billie's texts to make sure she really is who she says she is. She told them no and that they wouldn't find anything they wouldn't like. Greg told her that made no sense. He says she told him she didn't want to violate her friendship with Ayalla by allowing them to read their private texts. He marks this as her second lie and says it did not fool him. He told her to show him the texts or their relationship would be permanently over. He says as always, she gave up on her lie and revealed to him she smoked pot and would starve herself. He says he didn't want to punish her because they would encourage more lies, so he forgave her and they moved on. ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#77)
 
Greg says he and Kai wanted to look through Billie's texts to make sure she really is who she says she is. She told them no and that they wouldn't find anything they wouldn't like. Greg told her that made no sense. He says she told him she didn't want to violate her friendship with Ayalla by allowing them to read their private texts. He marks this as her second lie and says it did not fool him. He told her to show him the texts or their relationship would be permanently over. He says as always, she gave up on her lie and revealed to him she smoked pot and would starve herself. He says he didn't want to punish her because they would encourage more lies, so he forgave her and they moved on. ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#77)
Line 81: Line 81:
 
==November Break-Up==
 
==November Break-Up==
  
By late October, Billie and her best friend Ayalla visited Greg and Kai. At this time, Kai's online friend Sarah also had moved in. All three girls appeared in Greg's videos and on Greg and Kai's social media. By November 3rd, things seemed to already be amiss as viewers noticed Kai unfollowed Billie on twitter and deleted their Halloween couple photos from twitter. For the next few days, viewers speculated there was something wrong when Greg was frequently filming gaming videos with everyone but Kai. He was also posting many happy photos with the girls and only posted one photo of Kai looking sad or tired. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:EarlyNovember2016.png Source]) Some brushed this off as Kai was tried from taking care of the children.
+
By late October, Billie and her best friend Ayalla visited Greg and Kai. At this time, Kai's online friend Sarah also had moved in. All three girls appeared in Greg's videos and on Greg and Kai's social media. By November 3rd, things seemed to already be amiss as viewers noticed Kai unfollowed Billie on twitter and deleted their Halloween couple photos from twitter. For the next few days, viewers speculated there was something wrong when Greg was frequently filming gaming videos with everyone but Kai. He was also posting many happy photos with the girls and only posted one photo of Kai looking sad or tired. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:EarlyNovember2016.png Source]) Some brushed this off as Kaicould have just been tried from taking care of his children.
  
 
This all came to a halt by November 6th. Greg unfollowed Billie on twitter and finally posted a photo together with Kai with the caption "I guess you could say I'm having an ok day. 🤐🤕😐" ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:GregKaiPic11062016.png Source])
 
This all came to a halt by November 6th. Greg unfollowed Billie on twitter and finally posted a photo together with Kai with the caption "I guess you could say I'm having an ok day. 🤐🤕😐" ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:GregKaiPic11062016.png Source])
  
On November 9th, Greg uploaded the video "We Broke Up". Greg explains their relationship was a "trinity" because they all preformed sexual acts together. He says one night after he told Billie he loved her and that she was beautiful for the 50th time, Kai got upset. He said this was his breaking point. He told Kai there would be no more rules or boundaries in the relationship and that he would do whatever he wants. He explains Kai and Billie could do whatever they want together, but the relationship wasn't balanced or a "true trinity" because he couldn't do whatever he wants with Billie. He says Kai and her friend sat Billie down to talk that night, but no one told him about it. He the next day, he and Billie slept together and he was happy they were finally a true trinity. He says before sleeping with her, Billie tried to tell him Kai might be upset if they slept together. He says every time she brought it up, he would remind her of the conversation he had with Kai. He says Kai came home and he brought him upstairs to "make love", but first reiterated that he told him there would be no more rules or boundaries and told him he made love to Billie exclusively. He says Kai was very upset because in the secret conversation he had with Billie, he told Billie not to do anything exclusive with Greg and Billie agreed. He says when he and Kai confronted Billie, she kept making excuses saying she tried to tell Greg, but never got the words out. Greg says the problem is he asked Billie "do you want to?" and Billie would respond "duh" and "of course."
+
On November 9th, Greg uploaded the video "We Broke Up". Greg explains his relationship with Billie and Kai was a "trinity" because they all preformed sexual acts together. He says one night after he told Billie he loved her and that she was beautiful for the 50th time, Kai got upset. He said this was his breaking point. He told Kai there would be no more rules or boundaries in the relationship and that he would do whatever he wants. He explains Kai and Billie could do whatever they want together, but the relationship wasn't balanced or a "true trinity" because he couldn't do whatever he wants with Billie. He says Kai and her friend sat Billie down to talk that night, but no one told him about it. He the next day, he and Billie slept together and he was happy they were finally a true trinity. He says before sleeping with her, Billie tried to tell him Kai might be upset if they slept together. He says every time she brought it up, he would remind her of the conversation he had with Kai. He says Kai came home and he brought him upstairs to "make love", but first reiterated that he told him there would be no more rules or boundaries and told him he made love to Billie exclusively. He says Kai was very upset because in the secret conversation he had with Billie, he told Billie not to do anything exclusive with Greg and Billie agreed. He says when he and Kai confronted Billie, she kept making excuses saying she tried to tell Greg, but never got the words out. Greg says when he asked Billie "do you want to?" before they slept together, Billie would respond "duh" and "of course."
  
[[File:PupkinFuckYou.jpg|250px|thumb|right|"Fuck You" pumpkin]]Greg says Kai feels that Billie cheated on him because she specifically agreed not be "exclusively romantic" with Greg. Greg says he tried to defend Billie, but he asked her if Kai said they could not kiss when they were alone. He says Kai said he did and he couldn't defend her anymore because Billie initiated the kissing. He says he left to take a shower and Billie went into the woods to hit trees with a club. He says she took pieces of pumpkin they previously smashed for a video and spelled "fuck you" next to a noose she tied.  
+
[[File:PupkinFuckYou.jpg|250px|thumb|right|"Fuck You" pumpkin]]Greg says Kai feels that Billie cheated on him because she specifically agreed not be "exclusively romantic" with Greg. Greg says he tried to defend Billie, but he asked if Kai said they could not kiss when they were alone. He says Kai said he did and he couldn't defend her anymore because Billie initiated the kissing. He says he left to take a shower and Billie went into the woods to hit trees with a club. He says she took pieces of pumpkin they previously smashed for a video and spelled "fuck you" next to a noose she tied.  
  
 
Greg says during this time, Ayalla was having issues with her ex-boyfriend, Social Repose. He says she gave into SR's demands so he wouldn't make a video about her. Greg tweeted about the situation, calling out SR for threatening Ayalla to keep her silent. In the tweet, he says  
 
Greg says during this time, Ayalla was having issues with her ex-boyfriend, Social Repose. He says she gave into SR's demands so he wouldn't make a video about her. Greg tweeted about the situation, calling out SR for threatening Ayalla to keep her silent. In the tweet, he says  
SR has a twisted and sadistic sex life. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:TweetAboutSR11052016.png tweet]) In the video, Greg goes off of a text conversation he had with Billie. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:GregBillieTexts11052016.png texts]) Billie texted him, explaining Ayalla is crying because SR agreed to not talk about them, but now that Greg tweeted about their sex life they are afraid it is going to get worse. They believed this made Ayalla look bad for telling Greg about it. Greg says she not only told him, she told his nanny, Kai's friend, Kai, Billie. He goes into some of the details of their sex life. Greg reponds to Billie's texts, telling her he brought up his sex life to keep him from responding, that he needs to know it will get worse for him if he talks about it. Billie says she didn't want SR to expose dirt he has on her or Ayalla. She didn't want the internet to know she smoked weed. Greg responds "Moral of the story: Don't do illegal &/or horrible things." He goes on to mock her for being afraid she would be exposed for doing illegal things. After exchanging more texts, Billie apologizes and agrees with Greg.
+
SR has a twisted and sadistic sex life. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:TweetAboutSR11052016.png tweet]) In the video, Greg reads off of a text conversation he had with Billie. ([http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=File:GregBillieTexts11052016.png texts]) Billie texted him, explaining Ayalla is crying because SR agreed to not talk about them, but now that Greg tweeted about their sex life they are afraid things are going to get worse. She says this made Ayalla look bad for telling Greg about it. Greg says she not only told him, she told his nanny, Kai's friend, Kai, and Billie. He goes into some of the details of their sex life. Greg continues the read the texts. He responds to Billie, telling her he brought up his sex life to keep him from responding, that he needs to know it will get worse for him if he talks about it. Billie says she didn't want SR to expose dirt he has on her or Ayalla. She didn't want the internet to know she smoked weed. Greg responds "Moral of the story: Don't do illegal &/or horrible things." He goes on to mock her for being afraid she would be exposed for doing illegal things. After exchanging more texts, Billie apologizes and agrees with Greg.
  
[[File:Lillie.png|250px|right|thumb|Drawing Greg made of the "Lillie" tattoo]]Later that night, Greg texts Billie asking if she's okay and to meet in the garage. He says in the garage, it became clear Billie was trying to sneak out in the middle of the night with Ayalla. He says they already called an Uber and were going to stay with a friend. He says in the garage, he successfully convinced Billie to stay and told her she could win back he and Kai's trust if she got a tattoo of a lily with the word "Lillie" under it. He explains "Lillie" was Kai (who went by Lainey at the time) and Billie's names combined, their "ship name". He says he showed her his [http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=Tattoos#Remember_Love wrist tattoos] and told her if he was in her shoes he would do it because in the past he did something similar. He says Billie already had a lot of tattoos so it wasn't a big deal to get a pretty lily for Kai. He says Ayalla said this was fine, but as soon as he left the garage she convinced Billie to leave. He says Billie hugged him goodbye crying and he told her if she left there would be no going back. He says he walked her to the Uber and reiterated to her that she was abandoning them for good and that she was walking out when he was still fighting for her, but she still left.
+
[[File:Lillie.png|250px|right|thumb|Drawing Greg made of the "Lillie" tattoo]]Later that night, Greg texts Billie asking if she's okay and to meet in the garage. He says in the garage, it became clear Billie was trying to sneak out in the middle of the night with Ayalla. He says they already called an Uber and were going to stay with a friend. He says in the garage, he successfully convinced Billie to stay and told her she could win back he and Kai's trust if she got a tattoo of a lily with the word "Lillie" under it. He explains "Lillie" was Kai (who went by Lainey at the time) and Billie's names combined, their "ship name". He says he showed her his [http://www.lifeofonion.com/index.php?title=Tattoos#Remember_Love wrist tattoos] and told her if he was in her shoes he would do it because he already did something similar in the past. He says Billie already had a lot of tattoos so it wasn't a big deal to get a pretty lily for Kai. He says Ayalla said this was fine, but as soon as he left the garage she convinced Billie to leave. He says Billie hugged him goodbye crying and he told her if she left there would be no going back. He says he walked her to the Uber and reiterated to her that she was abandoning them for good and that she was walking out when he was still fighting for her, but she still left.
  
 
Greg says later on Billie sent Kai flowers. Greg text Billie, telling her if she truly loved Kai ad wanted to be with him again, she would get the tattoo to prove her dedication, never use drugs again, never lie, and to cut of Ayalla, who was the sole reason Billie left them that night. They exchange I love you's and he tells her to prove they can truest her. Billie did not reply to Greg's following texts and he says he believes that is the end of their association. ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#77)
 
Greg says later on Billie sent Kai flowers. Greg text Billie, telling her if she truly loved Kai ad wanted to be with him again, she would get the tattoo to prove her dedication, never use drugs again, never lie, and to cut of Ayalla, who was the sole reason Billie left them that night. They exchange I love you's and he tells her to prove they can truest her. Billie did not reply to Greg's following texts and he says he believes that is the end of their association. ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#77)
 +
 +
Four days later, Greg uploaded a follow up video titled "We Broke Up... But There's More". He starts off by defending the age gap in their relationship by pointing out everyone involved is a consenting adult. He addresses people that say the relationship is controlling or abusive and says these people have limited knowledge of the relationship because he's only talked about the negative sides of their relationship with Billie. He says he wants to talk about the positive sides. He talks about her appearance, her personality, and things they would do together. He says he's sad because he's probably never going to see her again, but he's not making this video in hopes he could change her mind about him because he doesn't think things are going to change. He says he and Kai really care about Billie, but won't get back together with her because of their issues. He says this video is more like a funeral than a love letter. He says no one was perfect in the relationship and Billie and himself were the most imperfect. He says they were "double trouble" because Billie was always on his side and go into battle with him against Kai. He says there should have never been battles against Kai and they should have been functioning in harmony. He says something he loves about Billie that's terrible is that she would show more affection toward him compared to Kai. He says it's a tragedy that they all couldn't work out the tiny bad part of the relationship and Kai is fighting himself to not text Billie. He says they are trying to heal. He defends releasing private information by saying in the past 8 years he has done this with ex friends and exes. He says it's so people can better understand him and themselves using his experiences. He says Billie has been civil toward him and Kai this whole time. He says he always uses the analogy that Kai is like a perfect cupcake and Billie was the sprinkles on top, making something perfect even better. ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#78)
 +
 +
A month later, on December 10th, Billie appeared in an UhOhBro gaming video with Greg, letting everyone know they were back together and she was once again back at their home. ([https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQlJG81isn8 $ource])
  
 
==Final Break-Up==
 
==Final Break-Up==
Line 100: Line 104:
 
: ''Main Article: [[Basementgate]]''
 
: ''Main Article: [[Basementgate]]''
  
..
+
On January 10, 2017, viewers once again notice Greg and Kai had unfollowed Billie on twitter and she had also unfollowed them. They each began posting dramatic social media. Greg tweeted various gifs of sad anime characters, Kai tweeted about how 2017 sucks, and Billie posted a new make-up look to instagram with the caption "sadness can be used for creativity."
 +
 
 +
The next day, Greg uploaded the video "Our Relationship Is Over" ([https://archive.org/details/youtube_UCZhkUguiTBJVZrrdMSjLbsQ Re-Upload]-#62)
  
 
=Post Relationship=
 
=Post Relationship=
  
Since Billie's final video she has not spoken about Greg or Lainey publicly. After the trinity, she dated a Youtuber, [[Drew]], who did reveal some information Billie told him privately about Greg and Kai which caused a brief online feud.  
+
After Billie's final video, she did not speak about Greg or Kai publicly. After the trinity, she dated a Youtuber, [[Drew]], who did reveal some information Billie told him privately about Greg and Kai which caused a brief online feud.  
  
 
Soon after the relationship, Kai would be trolled a lot on stream by fake Billie accounts in the comments. The trolls would try to "trigger" Kai and get a reaction from them. Kai would occasionally talk about his relationship with Billie.
 
Soon after the relationship, Kai would be trolled a lot on stream by fake Billie accounts in the comments. The trolls would try to "trigger" Kai and get a reaction from them. Kai would occasionally talk about his relationship with Billie.

Latest revision as of 16:34, 7 October 2019

Smurf50.png Smurf Says...
Warning! This page is not complete. There will be information and sources missing.
Greg and Billie in a 2016 video
Billie was Kai's (Greg's current spouse) girlfriend. After Greg cheated on Kai with Billie in 2016, he attempted to date Billie for a brief time before changing his mind and getting back together with Kai.

In the summer of 2016, Billie, Greg, and Kai began an on and off a poly relationship that ended January 2017.

**During the events in this article, Kai went by the nicknames "Lainey" or "Lain" and did not yet identify as a trans man. The writing in this article will reflect Kai's current name and pronouns, but images, quotes, and videos will not.

Early Relationship

Kai says he first noticed Billie on twitter when a photo of her was re-tweeted onto his timeline. Kai tweeted her asking her to be his girlfriend and to teach him how to do eyebrows. This was on August 19, 2015. (Source) Kai said he did not pursue a relationship until he saw Billie was single. He messaged her and asked if she was interested in girls and gave her her phone number. ($ource) It seems this happened in November 2015. (Source)

Billie was 18, Kai was 21, and Greg was 30 at this time.

Kai says Greg was the one that was pushing him to date Billie and that it was Greg's idea in the first place. (Source) Kai believed Greg did this because he would get something out of it. (Source)

Billie came to visit Kai and Greg in early December 2015. (Source) Greg says this was so Kai and Billie could get to know one another because they planned on dating. ($ource)

While Billie was over, Greg posted many statuses and images encouraging Billie and Kai's relationship. (Source) Greg started by posting an image of them kissing in the dark then continued encouraging them publicly, even calling them his OPT, or "one true pairing", a term usually used to describe a fan's favorite couple in a fictional story. (Source) Greg also made a sketch video titled "Onision's Wife Leaves Him (For A Woman)" where Billie and Kai intimately touched and talked about their lust for each other. The video ended with Kai and Billie making-out in-front of Greg acing horrified. ($ource) Greg also recorded some non-sketch videos with just Billie ($ource), something he would continue to do throughout their relationship.

Greg says during the visit, Kai became mad and even cried because Billie and Greg were spending a lot of the time together, rather than Billie concentrating on getting to know him. Kai felt that Billie might have been there for Greg and not really for him, but Billie denied this. Greg says he felt Kai was being unfair and encouraged him to give Billie another chance. Kai drove Billie to the airport when the trip was over. According to Greg, by the time they made it to the airport they were on good terms again. ($ource)

Kai says he was upset because Greg and Billie were flirting in-front of him, but they both denied it and told him he was being crazy. (Source)

Dating Kai

Kai and Billie kiss for Greg's video
Greg says 90% of his interactions with Billie were about how to make her relationship with Kai work and as time passed, he continued to encourage Kai to peruse Billie as a girlfriend. He says he even gave Billie money to buy a Christmas gift for Kai. Greg says eventually, Kai asked out Billie with a small letter and a CD of his favorite songs.

Greg says they got Billie another plane ticket to stay longer than last time. Greg says Kai was originally looking forward to it, until Billie missed the first flight. According to Greg, this confirmed Kai's suspicions that Billie was not interested in him. Kai told Greg he couldn't wait for Billie to leave before she even arrived. Despite this, Kai picked up Billie from the airport and they kissed. Greg says things seemed okay between them.

Greg said one night he, Kai, and Billie had a threesome, but Kai stopped it after getting to third base. The next day, Greg texted Kai telling Kai he was aroused and asked if he could cuddle Billie. According to Greg, this upset Kai and made him want to leave the house. As Greg was helping Kai pack, he told Kai, "[Billie] and I wouldn't do anything friends wouldn't do together." Greg later admits he was "clearly manipulating" Kai and "trying to slip something by [Kai]" when saying this because he had a female friend in high school he would "cuddle with on a regular basis" and he previously told Kai about this friend. After Kai left, Greg gave Billie a body massage that included her chest and butt. He justifies this by saying his mother was a masseuse and once gave him a full body massage with lotion, but avoided his gentiles. After the massage, they took individual showers, then cuddled while watching movies. He says they feel asleep cuddling in Kai's bed. Greg says they did not have sex.

The next day, Greg told Kai about what he did with Billie and Kai broke up with him. Sometime during their separation, Greg signed an agreement to give Kai a monthly sum of money and exclusive custody of their son. He also arranged for someone to help Kai five days a week with household chores. ($ource)

Dating Greg

After Kai left the house, Greg asked out Billie. (Source) He says just a few hour after he and Kai were separated, he asked Billie to kiss him and she told him "it was not the right time". He says this was because he was emotionally vulnerable. ($ource) Greg also said he told Billie, "Well it looks like you’re a homewrecker now", but she gave no response. (Source)

Greg released parts of his text conversations with Billie in a speaks video. In the first set of texts, Greg asks Billie if she is 100% sure if she wants to come back and she said yes. This was when Greg planned to fly Billie back up to his home 2 weeks after he and Kai broke up. (Source) The next set of texts shows Greg warning Billie about the internet backlash she will receive because of what happened. He also tells her he did not mention her name in his "I Betrayed My Wife" video. She tells him she can handle it. The last set of texts start out as a casual conversation where Billie tells Greg to contact her whenever he's feeling down, but ends with Greg cutting off contact with her by telling her he does not deserve love because of what he did and he needs to be alone. (Source)

Billie's friend at the time, Social Repose, claims that Billie told him after Greg and Billie broke up, Greg followed her to the airport he told her he would leave everything behind to start a new life with her. ($ource) Greg denied this happened. (Source)

First Separation

Main article: Cuddle Gate

On January 24, 2016, Kai tweeted "This changes everything" "I'm convinced I may actually die from heartache" "never again will I let someone in". Greg tweeted, "my wife can be so loving & is so beautiful. I'm lucky to be in her life." (Source) These types of tweets were not abnormal for Kai and Greg at the time so followers did not realize something serious had occurred until more information was revealed within the following days.

On the 25th, Kai tweeted a poll for his followers to answer yes or no to: "Is it cheating if you cuddle with someone (the gender youre attracted to) after you partner tells you it's not ok?" Kai seemed to agree that this did count as cheating as he re-tweeted a fan that replied it is considered cheating. Kai clarified some information with following tweets, saying this person was definitely attracted to the person they cuddled and they knew how their partner felt because they told them explicitly it wasn't ok. Kai also said they were not the one that cuddled someone. (Source) The same day, Greg made a tweet saying Kai is strong, beautiful, and smart and he deserves the best. (Source)

The next day, Kai revealed Greg and Billie had cuddled and slept in bed together while Kai wasn't home. (Source) Kai announced on Twitter he and Greg are separated. Kai also revealed Greg was in love with Billie and was already together with her. (Source)

Billie refused to talk about the situation on twitter, only saying she was not dating Greg. (Source) Billie later took to YouNow and eventually began talking to viewers about what happened, but refused to give any details. She defended Kai and Greg and said she wants them to get back together. (Source)

Greg uploaded two "I Betrayed My Wife" videos to his Speaks channel going into detail about what happened between him, Billie, and Kai. He revealed he and Kai were going to counseling to work on their marriage. ($ource)

The three of them received individual backlash from viewers for the events that took place. Billie in particular was labeled a "homewrecker" and was shunned by Greg and Kai as well as a majority of their fans. It is worth noting Greg and Kai's audience were not very familiar with Billie at this point as she only appeared in a couple of videos.

Greg released a prank "Re: Re: Re: I Betrayed My Wife" video to his comedy channel, pretending he and Kai broke up again. Billie thought it was real and sent Greg a text saying she caught feelings for him and and was ready for a relationship. Greg uploaded another fake "I Betrayed My Wife" to his comedy channel revealing the previous video was fake. He showed the text in his video and gave everyone that believed him the middle finger. (Source)

The "Ménage à Trois" aka The "Trinity"

Billie, Kai, and Greg in the background
In May 2016, Kai began expressing missing Billie on Twitter. (Source) Within the next two months, Kai slowly began talking more and more about Billie on Twitter and eventually posted a picture of him and Billie kissing for the Twitter hashtag "KeepKissing", a tag for LGBT couples to post kissing photos. (Source) By late June, Kai began tweeting about a girlfriend on Twitter and Billie would "like" his tweets. (Source)

Greg later revealed more details. He said Kai began communicating with Billie again, even though Greg had not spoken to Billie since the day he dropped her off at the airport. Greg says six months after their break-up, Kai wanted to take Billie back even though everyone around him, including Greg, told him this was a bad idea. (Source)

On June 29, 2016, Greg uploaded a picture of Kai to his Instagram where blue hair can be seen next to him. (Source) Many who suspected Billie was back were now convinced. The next day, Greg posted a seemingly random text rant in one of his videos where he explained he had multiple "amazing" threesomes with two "awesome" individuals and that the internet can try to shame them all they want. (Source) Greg began referring to their relationship as a ménage à trois in September and would continue until the rest of their relationship. (Source)

Brief Break-Ups

Billie visited Kai and Greg several times. This began a cycle where almost every time Billie would visit, Kai would break-up with her or get into a disagreement with her and sometimes Greg. Kai would vent on twitter about these fights, once even revealing Greg told him he did not want to be married to him anymore. (Source) Whenever this would happen, Greg and Billie would remain in contact over social media. If Billie was still at their house, Greg would sometimes take pictures with her and once recorded a video while Billie cuddled him (Source), which upset Kai. (Source) After Billie would leave their house and fly back home to the East Coast, everyone would be on good terms again and the cycle would begin again. Greg says he was the one that would always convince Kai to give Billie another chance. (Source)

Greg draws Billie, himself, and Kai.
After one of these break-ups, Greg made a video titled "My Wife and I Broke Up (Our Marriage Is Over)". In the video, he explains Kai's dramatic social media posts have been causing him and Billie "significant discomfort", so he wanted to give a "reasonable perspective" with this video. He blames Kai's insecurities about the three way relationship to make accusations against Billie. He says Kai's anxiety issues would make him think Billie was just there for Greg, despite Kai being the center of attention when they were all "in bed." He says Billie was dumped multiple times and was treated with negativity by Kai. Greg admits Billie was caught in lies during the relationship, but in the past he forgave Kai for lying to him, so he was happy to forgive Billie. He says Kai was not as lenient. He blames Kai's negativity, doubt, anxiety, and mistrust for all the times they sent Billie home crying. He says because Kai consistently mistreated Billie and destroyed their relationship so many times, he decided to break up with Kai. He says the reason they broke up is because for the 10th time, Kai went to twitter to trash talk Greg and Billie, but this time it was a lot more specific and malicious. He says he and Billie has never kissed or had sex without Kai and they would watch anime or play video games together when Kai was mad at them. He says he loves Billie, he doesn't have sex without love. He says he considers himself single, but there is a 90% chance he and Kai will work it out. ($ource)

After the video, Kai briefly deleted his twitter. When his twitter returned, the "dramatic" tweets were deleted and the cycle continued.

Greg later went on to explain some of their temporary break ups in a video. He explains Billie went to a concert and "multiple people" informed Kai that Billie appeared extremely high. (Note: It is well known that Greg does not allow his partners to smoke.) He says after the concert, Billie contacted him and Kai to ask if she could ever make "physical contact" with another guy. Greg says because he and Kai view this as a serious relationship, they said no. He explains allowing her to be with another guy would make their relationship "causal", therefor "meaningless." Greg says Billie told them she did not make physical contact with a guy, but Kai was informed of a photo of Billie holding another guy's hand at a concert while sitting on his shoulders. (Pic) Greg marks this as the first lie Billie told them. He says they broke up with Billie over this, but they soon forgave her and took her back. Since Billie's friend Ayalla tried to defend Billie to him over the phone during this time, Greg concludes Ayalla defends Billie over anything, even if Billie is wrong and calls them "partners in crime."

Greg says during this time, Billie managed his social media and was paid $1,800 a month for it. He says she was previously working at Target, but her schedule prevented her from hanging out with them. He mentions a perk of her working as a contractor for him was that she could fly out to hang out with them.

Greg says he and Kai wanted to look through Billie's texts to make sure she really is who she says she is. She told them no and that they wouldn't find anything they wouldn't like. Greg told her that made no sense. He says she told him she didn't want to violate her friendship with Ayalla by allowing them to read their private texts. He marks this as her second lie and says it did not fool him. He told her to show him the texts or their relationship would be permanently over. He says as always, she gave up on her lie and revealed to him she smoked pot and would starve herself. He says he didn't want to punish her because they would encourage more lies, so he forgave her and they moved on. (Re-Upload-#77)

November Break-Up

By late October, Billie and her best friend Ayalla visited Greg and Kai. At this time, Kai's online friend Sarah also had moved in. All three girls appeared in Greg's videos and on Greg and Kai's social media. By November 3rd, things seemed to already be amiss as viewers noticed Kai unfollowed Billie on twitter and deleted their Halloween couple photos from twitter. For the next few days, viewers speculated there was something wrong when Greg was frequently filming gaming videos with everyone but Kai. He was also posting many happy photos with the girls and only posted one photo of Kai looking sad or tired. (Source) Some brushed this off as Kaicould have just been tried from taking care of his children.

This all came to a halt by November 6th. Greg unfollowed Billie on twitter and finally posted a photo together with Kai with the caption "I guess you could say I'm having an ok day. 🤐🤕😐" (Source)

On November 9th, Greg uploaded the video "We Broke Up". Greg explains his relationship with Billie and Kai was a "trinity" because they all preformed sexual acts together. He says one night after he told Billie he loved her and that she was beautiful for the 50th time, Kai got upset. He said this was his breaking point. He told Kai there would be no more rules or boundaries in the relationship and that he would do whatever he wants. He explains Kai and Billie could do whatever they want together, but the relationship wasn't balanced or a "true trinity" because he couldn't do whatever he wants with Billie. He says Kai and her friend sat Billie down to talk that night, but no one told him about it. He the next day, he and Billie slept together and he was happy they were finally a true trinity. He says before sleeping with her, Billie tried to tell him Kai might be upset if they slept together. He says every time she brought it up, he would remind her of the conversation he had with Kai. He says Kai came home and he brought him upstairs to "make love", but first reiterated that he told him there would be no more rules or boundaries and told him he made love to Billie exclusively. He says Kai was very upset because in the secret conversation he had with Billie, he told Billie not to do anything exclusive with Greg and Billie agreed. He says when he and Kai confronted Billie, she kept making excuses saying she tried to tell Greg, but never got the words out. Greg says when he asked Billie "do you want to?" before they slept together, Billie would respond "duh" and "of course."

"Fuck You" pumpkin
Greg says Kai feels that Billie cheated on him because she specifically agreed not be "exclusively romantic" with Greg. Greg says he tried to defend Billie, but he asked if Kai said they could not kiss when they were alone. He says Kai said he did and he couldn't defend her anymore because Billie initiated the kissing. He says he left to take a shower and Billie went into the woods to hit trees with a club. He says she took pieces of pumpkin they previously smashed for a video and spelled "fuck you" next to a noose she tied.

Greg says during this time, Ayalla was having issues with her ex-boyfriend, Social Repose. He says she gave into SR's demands so he wouldn't make a video about her. Greg tweeted about the situation, calling out SR for threatening Ayalla to keep her silent. In the tweet, he says SR has a twisted and sadistic sex life. (tweet) In the video, Greg reads off of a text conversation he had with Billie. (texts) Billie texted him, explaining Ayalla is crying because SR agreed to not talk about them, but now that Greg tweeted about their sex life they are afraid things are going to get worse. She says this made Ayalla look bad for telling Greg about it. Greg says she not only told him, she told his nanny, Kai's friend, Kai, and Billie. He goes into some of the details of their sex life. Greg continues the read the texts. He responds to Billie, telling her he brought up his sex life to keep him from responding, that he needs to know it will get worse for him if he talks about it. Billie says she didn't want SR to expose dirt he has on her or Ayalla. She didn't want the internet to know she smoked weed. Greg responds "Moral of the story: Don't do illegal &/or horrible things." He goes on to mock her for being afraid she would be exposed for doing illegal things. After exchanging more texts, Billie apologizes and agrees with Greg.

Drawing Greg made of the "Lillie" tattoo
Later that night, Greg texts Billie asking if she's okay and to meet in the garage. He says in the garage, it became clear Billie was trying to sneak out in the middle of the night with Ayalla. He says they already called an Uber and were going to stay with a friend. He says in the garage, he successfully convinced Billie to stay and told her she could win back he and Kai's trust if she got a tattoo of a lily with the word "Lillie" under it. He explains "Lillie" was Kai (who went by Lainey at the time) and Billie's names combined, their "ship name". He says he showed her his wrist tattoos and told her if he was in her shoes he would do it because he already did something similar in the past. He says Billie already had a lot of tattoos so it wasn't a big deal to get a pretty lily for Kai. He says Ayalla said this was fine, but as soon as he left the garage she convinced Billie to leave. He says Billie hugged him goodbye crying and he told her if she left there would be no going back. He says he walked her to the Uber and reiterated to her that she was abandoning them for good and that she was walking out when he was still fighting for her, but she still left.

Greg says later on Billie sent Kai flowers. Greg text Billie, telling her if she truly loved Kai ad wanted to be with him again, she would get the tattoo to prove her dedication, never use drugs again, never lie, and to cut of Ayalla, who was the sole reason Billie left them that night. They exchange I love you's and he tells her to prove they can truest her. Billie did not reply to Greg's following texts and he says he believes that is the end of their association. (Re-Upload-#77)

Four days later, Greg uploaded a follow up video titled "We Broke Up... But There's More". He starts off by defending the age gap in their relationship by pointing out everyone involved is a consenting adult. He addresses people that say the relationship is controlling or abusive and says these people have limited knowledge of the relationship because he's only talked about the negative sides of their relationship with Billie. He says he wants to talk about the positive sides. He talks about her appearance, her personality, and things they would do together. He says he's sad because he's probably never going to see her again, but he's not making this video in hopes he could change her mind about him because he doesn't think things are going to change. He says he and Kai really care about Billie, but won't get back together with her because of their issues. He says this video is more like a funeral than a love letter. He says no one was perfect in the relationship and Billie and himself were the most imperfect. He says they were "double trouble" because Billie was always on his side and go into battle with him against Kai. He says there should have never been battles against Kai and they should have been functioning in harmony. He says something he loves about Billie that's terrible is that she would show more affection toward him compared to Kai. He says it's a tragedy that they all couldn't work out the tiny bad part of the relationship and Kai is fighting himself to not text Billie. He says they are trying to heal. He defends releasing private information by saying in the past 8 years he has done this with ex friends and exes. He says it's so people can better understand him and themselves using his experiences. He says Billie has been civil toward him and Kai this whole time. He says he always uses the analogy that Kai is like a perfect cupcake and Billie was the sprinkles on top, making something perfect even better. (Re-Upload-#78)

A month later, on December 10th, Billie appeared in an UhOhBro gaming video with Greg, letting everyone know they were back together and she was once again back at their home. ($ource)

Final Break-Up

Main Article: Basementgate

On January 10, 2017, viewers once again notice Greg and Kai had unfollowed Billie on twitter and she had also unfollowed them. They each began posting dramatic social media. Greg tweeted various gifs of sad anime characters, Kai tweeted about how 2017 sucks, and Billie posted a new make-up look to instagram with the caption "sadness can be used for creativity."

The next day, Greg uploaded the video "Our Relationship Is Over" (Re-Upload-#62)

Post Relationship

After Billie's final video, she did not speak about Greg or Kai publicly. After the trinity, she dated a Youtuber, Drew, who did reveal some information Billie told him privately about Greg and Kai which caused a brief online feud.

Soon after the relationship, Kai would be trolled a lot on stream by fake Billie accounts in the comments. The trolls would try to "trigger" Kai and get a reaction from them. Kai would occasionally talk about his relationship with Billie.

Greg talks often about his relationship with Billie in videos and in live streams. He will refer to her as "B" or his ex. As of 2018 he is still saying Billie's secret on stream and has the video up on his Encore channel where he talks about the secrets.

Relationships
Pre-YouTube Era JuliaChristinaShireeTashinaTanyaMinor Exes
Skye Era (2005 - 2010) Skye - Alimony
Shiloh Era (2010 - 2012) Shiloh - Shiloh Forgot MeShiloh Threatened MeThe Truth (Video)RogueSepsis

Hannah Minx - Annah Minx

Adrienne - The LetterSuk MiA Horrible ReboundThe Voicemails

Lainey Solo Era (2012 - 2016) Lainey - Snail Mail Stalker
"Trinity" Era (2016 - ongoing) Billie - CuddlegateThe TrinityBasementgate

LuxyMoo - Blue Hair Club